Tommy's Pizza Menu

Discover the menu and the specialties

Top picks at Tommy's Pizza

The dishes guests photograph and come back for.

  • Great Pizza

    Great Pizza

  • Classic Cheese Pizza Pie

    Classic Cheese Pizza Pie

  • Suppose to Be Crust on White Pizza

    Suppose to Be Crust on White Pizza

  • Cheese and Green Pepper Personal Pizza

    Cheese and Green Pepper Personal Pizza

  • Pepperoni Pizza

    Pepperoni Pizza

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Menu Highlights at Tommy's Pizza

The Plain Pie is a fundamental starting point, demonstrating the quality of ingredients used. It features a classic base of tangy tomato sauce and gooey cheese that melts beautifully together, creating a comforting and recognizable dish. This option suits those who enjoy the simple yet satisfying nature of a traditional pizza, allowing the crust and toppings to shine without excessive distractions.

For those seeking a little more kick, the Pepperoni Pie is a popular choice, praised for its savory slices of pepperoni that provide a nice crunch and a burst of flavor in each bite. This pizza is often what many think of when they picture a classic New York slice, making it perfect for newcomers looking to explore authentic local cuisine or seasoned pizza aficionados. The reviews consistently highlight the perfect amount of grease and crispiness, making it a fan favorite.

The Sausage Pie is another standout, known for delivering generous chunks of savory sausage that give each slice a hearty bite. The combination of meat and the fresh, zesty sauce creates a flavor-packed option that appeals to meat lovers and adds a satisfying element to the dining experience. It's an excellent pick for those wanting something more substantial than traditional toppings.

The Garlic Small Pie offers a unique twist for garlic enthusiasts. The flavorful aroma complements the cheese and crust well, providing a robust representation of what a garlic pizza should embody. Guests looking for a lighter option, but still packed with flavor, will find this dish appealing. Whether enjoyed alone or alongside other toppings, it’s a dish that speaks to a more adventurous palate.

Tommy's Pizza - photo 1

How to Order at Tommy's Pizza

For those visiting Tommy's Pizza for the first time, starting with the plain pizza is an excellent choice. It offers a simple yet authentic taste that embodies the essence of what makes New York pizza beloved. If dining in with family or friends, consider ordering a large pie to share, allowing for the experience of sampling various toppings without overwhelming portions. Taking some slices home can also be a great option, as the flavors maintain their quality when reheated.

Sharing is highly encouraged here, given the sizes of the pies. With options for both large and small, there's plenty to go around, so feel free to mix and match among different topping types. This approach not only makes for a fun dining experience but also maximizes value by allowing everyone to enjoy a bit of everything, from classic pepperoni to savory chicken.

Tommy's Pizza is also cash-only, so it's wise to prepare your payment method beforehand. While this can be less convenient for some, it emphasizes the retro charm of this classic pizzeria. For takeaway or delivery, make sure to place your order ahead during peak hours to avoid long waits, especially on weekends or late evenings. The staff is accommodating and efficient, making the process smooth once the order is in.

In terms of dietary needs, Tommy's Pizza accommodates various preferences, making it an inclusive stop for different patrons. While not explicitly noted, the nature of customization with toppings helps cater to those seeking vegetarian options or specific flavor profiles. Overall, value shines here, as patrons consistently rave about the pizza quality in relation to the price, making it a worthwhile add to any pizza lover's itinerary.

Tommy's Pizza - photo 2