Pizza restaurant4.6· 839 reviews

Tommy's Pizza

Bronx, New York

Enjoy authentic NY-style pizza at Tommy's Pizza in the Bronx. Known for crispy, thin crust slices, old-school charm, cash-only convenience, and late hours. Visit us at 4033 E Tremont Ave for a true neighborhood favorite!

Guest rating
4.6/ 5
Reviews
839
Category
Pizza restaurant
City
Bronx
Usual hours
10 AM-11 PM

About Tommy's Pizza

Tommy's Pizza sits at 4033 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10465. This beloved pizzeria is well-known for its classic New York-style pizza, characterized by its thin, crispy crust and generous toppings. With a warm, welcoming atmosphere and an old-school vibe, it serves as a neighborhood hangout for pizza lovers of all ages. The restaurant offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options, making it a convenient choice for anyone craving a delicious pie.

At Tommy's, pizza is more than just food; it's a tradition. The inviting interior invites customers to enjoy a slice in a casual setting, often buzzing with local patrons. Open late on weekends, it’s the perfect place to satisfy a late-night craving with friends or family. With a menu that emphasizes both quality and value, Tommy's builds a strong connection with its community, cementing its status as a top pizza spot in the Bronx.

Tommy's Pizza has carved out a niche in the Bronx as a go-to spot for authentic New York pizza. Known for its large 8-slice pies and small 6-slice offerings, each pizza boasts a perfect balance of sauce, cheese, and toppings. The menu features crowd-pleasers like pepperoni, sausage, chicken, and bacon, ensuring that there’s something for everyone. With 19 different options, including unique variations like meat sauce and garlic, there’s endless pizza to explore.

The setting of Tommy's Pizza exudes warmth and friendliness. Located in a vibrant neighborhood, it draws in passersby and regulars alike who are looking to indulge in a slice of goodness. The old-school pizzeria vibe is apparent, with a comfortable, no-frills ambiance that fosters a sense of community. The restaurant is designed to be accessible, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking, making it easy for everyone to enjoy a meal.

Tommy's has built a loyal customer base, with many reviewers praising the exceptional quality of the pizza. Consistently high ratings emphasize the restaurant's dedication to perfecting its craft—customers rave about the crispy crust, gooey cheese, and flavorful toppings. This passion for pizza comes through in every bite, making the experience memorable. The welcoming staff adds to the charming atmosphere, ensuring that every visit feels like coming home.

As a slice of Bronx culture, Tommy's Pizza stands out among pizzerias by offering not just food, but a communal experience filled with laughter and stories. It serves as a gathering spot where friends reminisce over shared meals, and every pizza order tells a story. This combination of quality and atmosphere makes Tommy's not just a restaurant, but a cornerstone of the Bronx culinary landscape.

What guests say about Tommy's Pizza

Guests often praise

  • The crispy crust that has the perfect bite, drawing in customers who appreciate that classic pizza texture.
  • Generous cheese and sauce portions that create a deliciously gooey experience with each slice, often described as the perfect pizza ratio.
  • The friendly and welcoming staff who add a personal touch to the dining experience, making patrons feel right at home.
  • The overall value, with large pies providing enough food to satisfy even the heartiest appetites, all at reasonable prices.
  • The late-night hours on weekends, allowing for a quick and satisfying pizza run after a long day or night out.

Worth knowing

  • Some customers note the cash-only policy, which can be inconvenient for those who prefer electronic payments.
  • A few patrons have commented on the crowded seating area during peak hours, which can affect the dining experience.
  • Occasionally, certain toppings may run out, particularly on busy nights, limiting options for some customers.
  • While many love the crust, a small number of reviews have mentioned wanting a slightly thicker option, indicating a variety of crust preferences among diners.

Best for

  • Families seeking a casual dining experience with delicious pizza options that everyone can enjoy.
  • Late-night diners looking for a hearty meal after hours—perfect for a snack or a full meal.
  • Local residents wanting a familiar spot to grab a quick slice or a whole pie on busy weeknights.
  • Pizza enthusiasts eager to savor authentic New York pizza in a welcoming, community-oriented environment.

Customer Experiences at Tommy's Pizza

Customers consistently rave about their experiences at Tommy's Pizza, praising not just the food but the entire dining atmosphere. The inviting space is filled with the delicious aroma of freshly baked pizza, creating an appealing environment for guests. Reviewers frequently highlight the perfect execution of each pizza, noting that the crust is crispy without being overly oily, making it a pleasurable eat. Many express delight over the gooey cheese and the well-balanced sauce, indicating that Tommy's delivers on the signature New York pizza experience brilliantly.

Service is another standout feature that customers commend. Guests consistently report feeling welcomed, with the friendly staff ensuring that everyone is taken care of. Many reviews mention how the staff goes the extra mile, providing excellent service that leaves a lasting impression—not just on the meal but the entire dining experience. Patrons also feel valued and appreciated, making each visit memorable and inviting. The personal touch adds to the restaurant's charm, encouraging many to return.

Value for money is often a focal point in reviews, with many customers citing affordable prices paired with generous portions. The cash-only policy may seem outdated, but many patrons view it as a part of the old-school charm that Tommy's embodies. Regulars often express satisfaction with the quality they receive for the price, making it a go-to dining option for many. The consistent quality of the pizza receives accolades, with many reviewers noting that they have yet to encounter a disappointing experience. Some highlight specific items they keep coming back for, emphasizing the menu's balance and reliability across all options. The fact that so many people have dedicated personal favorites serves as a testament to the establishment's commitment to excellence.

Overall, Tommy's Pizza stands out not just for its pizza but for the entire experience. From the delightful atmosphere to friendly service and remarkable food, customers often describe it as a an essential stop in the Bronx for anyone craving an authentic slice.

Top picks at Tommy's Pizza

The dishes guests photograph and come back for.

View Full Menu
  • Great Pizza

    Great Pizza

  • Classic Cheese Pizza Pie

    Classic Cheese Pizza Pie

  • Suppose to Be Crust on White Pizza

    Suppose to Be Crust on White Pizza

  • Cheese and Green Pepper Personal Pizza

    Cheese and Green Pepper Personal Pizza

  • Pepperoni Pizza

    Pepperoni Pizza

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

What Tommy's Pizza offers

Services, accessibility, payments and more, grouped as the place lists them.

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible car park

Opening hours

When Tommy's Pizza is open during the week.

Opening hours
Monday10 AM-11 PM
Tuesday10 AM-11 PM
Wednesday10 AM-11 PM
Thursday10 AM-11 PM
Friday10 AM-12 AM
Saturday10 AM-12 AM
Sunday10 AM-11 PM
Call for information+1 718-829-2828
ContactWhatsApp

Hours can change on holidays. Call ahead to be sure.

Planning Your Visit to Tommy's Pizza

Tommy's Pizza operates Monday through Thursday from 10 AM to 11 PM, extending hours until midnight on Friday and Saturday, which gives plenty of time to satisfy your pizza cravings. However, weekends can get particularly busy, especially in the evenings. For a quieter experience, consider visiting during a weekday morning or an early afternoon when operations are smoother and less crowded, allowing for a more relaxed dining experience.

The pizzeria is easily accessible, featuring a wheelchair-accessible entrance and parking, ensuring it accommodates all guests. If you're driving, street parking is available in the vicinity, but be wary of regulations to avoid tickets. For those relying on public transport, checking local bus routes ahead of time can save some time and ensure a seamless transition from commute to delicious slices.

Payment at Tommy's is cash-only, a policy that some might find inconvenient. To avoid disruption during your meal, it’s wise to come prepared with cash in hand. In the age of digital payments, this old-school approach adds a certain nostalgia and connects you even more to the traditional pizza experience—making it important to keep this detail in mind as you plan your visit.

Every pizza is made-to-order, so patience is recommended during busy hours. This ensures fresh ingredients and quality output, but it may require a short wait. Conversations with nearby diners can brighten the wait time, and the delicious smell of pizza wafting through the pizzeria makes anticipation all the more worthwhile. As a crowd-favorite spot for locals, it’s an experience best shared with friends or family.

How to get there

Address

4033 E Tremont Ave, Bronx, NY 10465, United States

Photos of Tommy's Pizza

Show all photos (12)

Reviews of Tommy's Pizza

What recent visitors say, and how the ratings add up.

4.6/ 5

Based on 839 reviews

Rating distribution

  • 579%
  • 410%
  • 34%
  • 22%
  • 15%
  • Riccardo C.2026-10-18

    Best pizza in the Bronx

  • SwizzyXQL2026-10-16

    The pizza was perfect so delicious! It wasn't too oily it was the perfect size texture, the cheese oh my god it's really good.

  • Ben C.2026-09-24

    Absolutely perfect just the right amount of sauce, gooey cheese, and toasty crust. Best pie ive had in NY so far.

Show all reviews (9)
  • Theresa B.2026-09-23

    Hidden gem! Amanda so kind! Great pizza! We ll be back!

  • Luis L.2026-09-16

    Best pizza I have thank you

  • Douglas H.2026-08-31

    Still great service and phenomenal pizza

  • Willoughby L.2026-08-30

    Old school pizzeria...this is the best pizza in the Bronx! I ordered a pie and ate 5 slices in my car before I got home!

  • Kenneth M.2026-07-30

    I've been coming here for years, and once you walk through the door, you know what you're getting: a great slice of pizza! Consistency is key.

  • Yeyka R.2026-06-20

    We love this pizzeria. Pizza here is 10/10 Nice staff, delicious food and clean.

How Tommy's Pizza scores

Scored out of 10 from what reviewers say. Topics they do not mention are left out.

  • Food quality10/10
  • Service quality10/10
  • Customer service10/10

Frequently asked questions

What are the opening hours for Tommy's Pizza?

Tommy's Pizza is open daily from 10 AM to 11 PM. On Fridays and Saturdays, the hours extend until midnight. Whether it's a weekday or the weekend, there's plenty of time to grab a slice.

Does Tommy's Pizza offer delivery or takeaway?

Yes, Tommy's Pizza provides both delivery and takeaway options for those who prefer to enjoy their pizza at home. Conveniently place an order and opt for the service that suits you best.

What should I order at Tommy's Pizza?

The menu features large pies with eight slices, offering options like plain, pepperoni, and sausage, as well as small pies with six slices, including garlic and meat sauce. The thin crust and crispy texture are highlights that keep customers returning.

Is there parking available at Tommy's Pizza?

Yes, there is a wheelchair-accessible car park available for visitors. Parking should be convenient for anyone looking to stop in for a delicious slice.

What are the payment options at Tommy's Pizza?

Tommy's Pizza operates on a cash-only basis. Be sure to grab some cash before heading over to enjoy their fantastic pizza.